[M | t | ★★★★] | keywords:electromagnetic
induction, Lenz's Law, magnetic levitation
What it shows: A changing magnetic flux induces
a current in a metal ring; the magnetic field due to this current
opposes the primary field, repelling the ring and flinging it into
the air. That's the simple "hand waving" explanation for the
beginner student—a more accurate explanation follows.
How it really works: The jumping ring is a
vivid and popular demonstration of electromagnetic induction and is
used to illustrate Faraday's and Lenz's laws. A conducting ring,
placed over the ferromagnetic core of a solenoid, may levitate or
jump off when the solenoid is energized with sufficient 60-Hz
alternating current. The changing magnetic flux induces an
emf in the metal ring, producing a large current in the
ring. The Lorentz force between the magnetic field and the induced
current propels the ring.
The axial magnetic field of the iron core is responsible for
inducing the current in the ring. The radial magnetic field
provides the Lorentz force. Thus, the magnetic field must diverge
out of the iron core since both axial and radial components are
necessary for the effect. While this explanation is quite correct
for an increasing magnetic field (as in the first 1/4 cycle), it is
not the full story. Invoke the explanation for the case of
alternating current and you will deduce that the net force
(time-averaged over a complete cycle) is zero. There is one more
subtle but very important feature that explains the effect in an AC
magnetic field. See the
Attractive and Repulsive Phases demonstration in-depth write-up
for a graphical analysis of this.
The important feature missing from the explanation is the fact that
the ring has an inductance. While this inductance is very small
(0.043 μH)1, so is the DC
resistance (61 μΩ)2. The
total impedance of the ring is 63 μΩ, and there is a 15 degree
phase angle between the induced emf and current in the
ring. This phase angle is responsible for a non-zero time-averaged
force. Decreasing the DC resistance (by cooling the Al ring in LN2)
will not only increase the current in the ring, but will also
increase the phase angle so that the Lorentz force on the ring is
considerably greater (the ring hits the ceiling). If you increase
the DC resistance (by using a stainless steel ring, for example),
the phase angle is so small that no force can be detected on the
ring.
It's also fun (and instructive) to hold one ring above (and close
to) another hovering ring. The induced parallel currents in the two
rings result in an attractive force between them, and the lower
ring rises to touch the upper ring!
Much less obvious is why a stack of five narrow rings will hover
higher than one single ring whose width is the same as the stack of
five. An excellent and thorough analysis is given by P.J.H. Tjossem
and V. Cornejo, "Measurements and mechanisms of Thomson's jumping
ring," AJP 68(3), 238-244 (2000). See also
P.J.H. Tjossem and E.C. Brost, "Optimizing Thomson's jumping ring,"
AJP 79(4), 353-358 (2011).
 |
 |
Apparatus details: The solenoid sits vertically
with the iron core—a 60cm long cluster of 1mm iron rods—resting
inside it and protruding 42cm. The solenoid is a 400 turn coil with
an air core inductance of 4.7mH, wound with 14 AWG wire insulated
for 110V. The coil is connected to 110V AC.
Several rings are available. The "standard" ring is aluminum, 2 cm
wide, 3.6 mm wall thickness, and 4.2 cm inner diameter to fit
loosely over the core. Place the ring on top of the solenoid and
turn on the power; the ring will shoot off the end of the core to a
height of about 2m. Alternatively, turn on the power and place the
ring over the core, and it will hover about half way up. A second
aluminum ring is identical save for a split, which prevents a
circuital current being set up so no field can be generated; the
ring just sits there. Also available is a 50 turn (20AWG) wire loop
connected to an 18V bulb. The induced EMF lights the bulb when the
ring is lowered over the iron core; its brightness will increase
dramatically as you move the ring down (see
Comments).
figure 1. The Ring Flinger

Setting it up:
The flinger sits on the lecture bench. Make sure the iron core is
in place before turning on the supply; the low inductance will blow
a fuse.
Comments:
For a much more spectacular fling, dip the ring into liquid
nitrogen. This is explained in the
Jumping Ring demo. Take care when using the coil and bulb, as
it can easily burn out if dropped to the base of the rod, due to
the very large flux down there. Apparently the jumping ring was
first demonstrated by Elihu Thomson in May 1887 to the American
Institute of Electrical Engineers in New York to help promote the
supremacy of his ac dynamos over Edison's dc system.3
1 The
inductance was calculated using the general equation on page 105,
Chapt 13 of Frederick Grover, Inductance Calculations, (D
Van Nostrand, 1946). The result agrees with another formula on page
95 for coils of square cross section.
2 The
resistance was calculated for 6063 aluminum alloy, which has a
resistivity = 3.32x10-6Ω-cm.
3 Noel
Barry and Richard Casey, "Elihu Thomson's Jumping Ring in a
Levitated Closed-Loop Control Experiment," IEEE Transactions on
Education 42:1 (February 1999): 72-80.
Back |